Original Sin Is A Lie

Guides / The Gospels disagree

A guide

The Gospels disagree

And that's freeing, not frightening

A brown ink and wash drawing of the four evangelists, bearded men writing and reading together
Circle of Domenico Beccafumi, Four Evangelists, 1542–46. Pen and brown ink with wash. Art Institute of Chicago.

My brother-in-law, a devout Catholic I love dearly, once listened to me go on about the mystics for an entire evening. Then he said, kindly, "I appreciate what you're saying, but I just don't think it's okay to pick and choose." I hear that a lot. But the Gospels themselves don't agree on the details. Once you see that, picking and choosing isn't a betrayal of the Bible. It's the only honest way to read it.

How we got four

Four authors, four communities, four decades

Then came centuries of hand copying. We have over five thousand Greek manuscripts of the New Testament, and no two are exactly alike. Most of the differences are spelling slips, but not all of them.

See for yourself

Places they don't line up

  1. Two different family trees.

    Matthew traces Jesus back to Abraham through King Solomon, and names Joseph's father Jacob (Matthew 1:1–16). Luke goes all the way back to Adam through a different son of David, Nathan, and names Joseph's father Heli (Luke 3:23–38).

  2. The temple, at opposite ends.

    In Mark, Jesus overturns the money changers' tables in his final week, and it helps get him killed (Mark 11:15–18). In John, it happens at the very start of his ministry (John 2:13–16).

  3. A sign, or no sign?

    In Mark, Jesus says "no sign will be given to this generation" (Mark 8:12). In Matthew, no sign will be given "but the sign of Jonah the prophet" (Matthew 12:39).

  4. Who was at the tomb?

    Mark: a young man in white (16:5). Matthew: an angel who rolled the stone away (28:2). Luke: two men in dazzling clothes (24:4). John: Mary Magdalene finds it empty, and later sees two angels (20:1, 20:12).

  5. His last words.

    A psalm of abandonment in Mark and Matthew, forgiveness and peace in Luke, and "It is finished" in John. (More here.)

  6. Mark's ending.

    The oldest manuscripts of Mark stop at 16:8, with the women running from the empty tomb, afraid. The appearances, the snake handling, and the ascension in 16:9–20 were added later.

So now what

Get archaeological

None of this means the Gospels are worthless. The Sermon on the Mount is sublime. The Good Samaritan and the Prodigal Son can still crack your heart open. It means the Bible is a human document, written by real people for real communities, with all the fingerprints that leaves. Divinely inspired? From where I sit, absolutely, the way all great scripture is. Infallible? The texts themselves say no.

So dig. Ask who wrote each passage, when, and for whom. Keep what carries the teaching of love. Set down what was added to scare people into line. Everyone picks and chooses, including the people who say they don't. The question is whether you choose from fear or from love.

Watch: dozens of legitimate contradictionsA reel on the places the Bible disagrees with itself.
Cover of Original Sin Is A Lie
In the bookChapter 1, "Why It's Okay to Pick and Choose," goes through the timeline and the contradictions in detail.
Keep going

Where to next

Guide

How to read the Bible again

Where to start, which translation, and what to ask of every passage.

Verse

Mark 15:34

"My God, why have you forsaken me?" And the psalm it came from.

Guide

Paul

He never met Jesus, and most scholars think he didn't write half the letters with his name on them.